Monday, April 20, 2009

Draft 1 - Gatsby

The Great Gatsby depicts the theme of the American dream perfectly because the characters have have the perfect life, have many oppurtunities for things, and are wealthy.
  • In The Great Gatsby, they make it seem that their lives are perfect, on the exterior to everyone else. But in reality they're many relationships that are troubled and affairs. Tom was having an affair with Myrtle that everyone knew about, but no one said anything about it because they didn't want to start an arguement and show others their problems. "She was only extemporizing but a stirring warmth flowed from her as if her heart was trying to come out to you concealed in one of those breathless, thrilling words." (Fitzgerald, 19)

  • All of the main characters in the book were wealthy. Tom, Daisy and Nick had old wealth from their family names and Gatsby had new wealth. Gatsby used his wealth to impress Daisy so he could get her back. Tom and Daisy are horrible people and when things go bad or not the way they want to go, they fall back on their money and take a trip or move, just to get away. "They were careless people, Tom and Daisy--they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money of their vast carelessness, or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made." (Fitzgerald, 183).

  • Living the American dream means that one has many oppurtunties for different things and achieving one's goals. Gatsby was a man that lived by strict rules, and at the end his father said that he was gonna be successful. "Jimmy was bound to get ahead. He always had some resolves like this or something." (Fitzgerald, 182). Gatsby's first dream was to be successful and make lots of money but all that changed when he met Daisy, then all he wanted was to have her, which was his downfall and the reason why he lost both his success and Daisy.
  • Gatsby threw his chances of happiness away when he starting lying to his friends in order to take Daisy back from Tom. Because he tried so hard to keep her in his life, he made the mistake of taking the blame for her and that was the reason Wilson went for him, and shot him. If Gatsby would have been more truthful and would let go of the past, he would have had a much more successful life and he wouldn't have been murdered like he was.

5 comments:

  1. Introduction effectively sets up argument and engages reader ?
    Thesis is clear, concise, and poses a worthy argument +
    Body paragraphs are persuasive +
    Strongest point is last -
    Paragraphs directly support argument in thesis +
    Citations are relevant and support argument +
    Citations are cited correctly using MLA +
    Conclusion ties up ideas and leaves the reader with something to consider -
    Conclusion does not restate thesis +
    All paragraphs are a minimum of 5-7 sentences +
    needs a conclusion, put it in the form of a paper

    ReplyDelete
  2. Introduction effectively sets up argument and engages reader
    Thesis is clear, concise, and poses a worthy argument
    Body paragraphs are persuasive
    Strongest point is last
    Paragraphs directly support argument in thesis
    Citations are relevant and support argument
    Citations are cited correctly using MLA
    Conclusion ties up ideas and leaves the reader with something to consider
    Conclusion does not restate thesis
    All paragraphs are a minimum of 5-7 sentences

    Has the writer convinced you? Why or why not?

    Additional comments/suggestions



    Overall rating out of 10 (10 is highest)
    Defend rating
    John, you have good ideas. I think you need to add a paragraph or two. I am going to give a "?" to you. so maybe ill give you a 7/10 cause your special and creative.
    John you havent totally sold me on the idea but your getting there.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Introduction effectively sets up argument and engages reader +
    Thesis is clear, concise, and poses a worthy argument +
    Body paragraphs are persuasive +
    Strongest point is last ?
    Paragraphs directly support argument in thesis +
    Citations are relevant and support argument +
    Citations are cited correctly using MLA +
    Conclusion ties up ideas and leaves the reader with something to consider -
    Conclusion does not restate thesis +
    All paragraphs are a minimum of 5-7 sentences +

    Has the writer convinced you? Why or why not?
    Yes, was very clear and well typed
    Additional comments/suggestions



    Overall rating out of 10 (10 is highest) 8
    Defend rating
    had lots of info and was persuasive

    ReplyDelete
  4. Introduction effectively sets up argument and engages reader+
    Thesis is clear, concise, and poses a worthy argument+
    Body paragraphs are persuasive?
    Strongest point is last-
    Paragraphs directly support argument in thesis+
    Citations are relevant and support argument+
    Citations are cited correctly using MLA+
    Conclusion ties up ideas and leaves the reader with something to consider?
    Conclusion does not restate thesis?
    All paragraphs are a minimum of 5-7 sentences+

    Has the writer convinced you? Why or why not?

    The basic examples of why GG represents the american life is very convincing but this paper could include more detail

    Additional comments/suggestions



    Overall rating out of 10
    6

    ReplyDelete
  5. Introduction effectively sets up argument and engages reader+
    Thesis is clear, concise, and poses a worthy argument+
    Body paragraphs are persuasive?
    Strongest point is last?
    Paragraphs directly support argument in thesis+
    Citations are relevant and support argument+
    Citations are cited correctly using MLA+
    Conclusion ties up ideas and leaves the reader with something to consider?
    Conclusion does not restate thesis-
    All paragraphs are a minimum of 5-7 sentences?

    Has the writer convinced you? Why or why not?
    He has a convincing argument, but needed a closing paragraph. Good job supporting his thoughts though.
    Additional comments/suggestions
    Good job supporting your opinion. You need a closing paragraph and additional sentences in opening paragraph.


    Overall rating out of 10 (10 is highest)8
    Defend rating
    Good supporting and thoughts, but missing a closing paragraph and a part of the first paragraph. Otherwise, very well done.

    ReplyDelete